Toronto Public Library Workers Union

From the Torontoist.....

2016 Budget Preview: The Toronto Public Library
The Toronto Public Library argues that it needs more capital spending to keep up with reader demand.

BY 

This article is part of Torontoist’s special 2016 municipal budget coverage. If you value journalism like this and you’d like to see it year-round, then subscribe now. You’ll help fund a staff writer to hold City Hall accountable, and be a member of Raccoon Nation.


Photo by photoanalysis from the Torontoist Flickr Pool  Photo by photoanalysis from the Torontoist Flickr Pool.

Library-goers in the post-Ford era are breathing easy now that their cherished institution no longer faces severe budget cuts. Ever since the 6 per cent budget decrease the Toronto Public Library system faced in 2012—the mayor’s office wanted a 10 per cent reduction—net expenditures have been on a gradual incline. With an average operating budget increase of 0.5 per cent over the past five years, budget increases have been much lower than inflation.The librarians have since put down their picket signs, and Anika Tabovaradan won the battle for her library to stay open after school. But the libraries’ fiscal woes are not over just yet—the TPL’s biggest obstacle lies within their long-term capital budget plan.

The Operating Budget


Before we get to the capital budget, let’s take a look at the operating budget (which funds ongoing annual expenditures, like staff salary). This year, the library board looks to boost their operating budget by $3.4 million to $192 million—a 1.8 per cent increase over last year’s budget. The proposed number accounts primarily for salary and benefit costs as well as contracted services. But the final number could change as the Budget Committee and Council starts to address the budget proposals on December 15 (the proposed budgets are usually greater than what City Council approves).

This year’s proposal comes with stats outlining a 13.5 per cent increase of total library use over the past decade. The libraries have experienced a 7.5 per cent increase for in-person visits, a 4.8 per cent increase in total circulation, and a hefty 40.9 per cent rise in “virtual visits”—a victory that can largely be credited to the department’s capital spending on Virtual Branch Services.

Due to an increasing demand for online material such as e-books and e-magazines, and “unreasonably high prices” charged by publishers, the budget proposal allocates $220,000 towards material and supply expenditures for their growing e-collection. The budget submission adds that digital content has increased by 250 per cent since 2012.

The Capital Budget


On the other end, the board has proposed a $28.3 million capital budget for 2016 as part of a $321.8 million plan to be dispensed over the next 10 years. Among various long-term TPL projects, the proposal includes renovations and expansions at the Wychwood and Dawes Road branches, a relocation of the Perth/Dupont branch, and, as part of a joint effort with the Parks, Forestry and Recreation department, additional funding for an underground parking lot at the Bayview branch.

But the long-term proposal could face serious questions during the budget process. Currently, the City’s debt target sits at $153.7 million over the next 10 years, while the TPL’s proposed capital budget exceeds that number by $71.3 million—a 46 per cent overage.

The 2016-2025 Capital Budget and Plan Update from the Library argues that the City’s assigned targets are “inadequate to meet TPL’s capital funding needs for building [state of good repair]” (the libraries’ multi-branch renovation program). The update adds that, because the debt targets are not adjusted for inflation in 2018, the target would create an increased backlog for the renovation program. Despite the $71.3 million in proposed spending that exceeds the debt target, there would still be a remaining $73 million backlog by 2025. The SOGR expenses become especially crucial as library usage increases—and so far, it has.

From the Toronto Public Library's 2016 Budget Proposal, pp  9 [PDF]  From the Toronto Public Library’s 2016 Budget Proposal, pp. 9 [PDF].


Despite increasing capital needs, the City requests a decrease in the Library’s debt target (blue). The green in this graph tracks what the increase would need to be to track with inflation, while the white is what the library says is needed to keep their capital needs in good stead.The last two years saw a variety of big capital ventures for the TPL, including two new branches in Fort York and Scarborough Centre. The branches cost $9.1 and $10.2 million respectively, and have attracted attention for their swanky features—3D printers, digital innovation hubs, and DJ equipment for Toronto’s aspiring Tiësto’s. Each branch holds roughly 40,000 books, provides access to over a dozen public access computers and Wi-Fi, and are well-used.

The Library is a beloved Toronto institution, as the response to the Ford-era budget cuts showed. How much Council is willing to fund its growth and support reader demand—particularly on the capital side—is an open question, and how councillors respond to this budget cycle will go a long way to provide the answer.


Did you like this article? Do you love Torontoist? Support articles like this by becoming one of the first Torontoist subscribers. Get great perks and fund local journalism that makes a difference—join Raccoon Nation now.

Librarian Glasses

Members Login Here:

Twitter icon

Recent Tweets

May 10
RT @LibrarianshipCA: They threatened to read — so a PC MPP’s office called the cops https://t.co/nQwfn3woM0 Throw the book at ’em has take…
May 09
Shame on @MichaelTibollo at a $1600 plate PC fundraiser after slashing N & S #publiclibrary budgets by 50%.… https://t.co/bDB6yTzVv0
May 09
RT @progresstoronto: Did you send an email to your MPP to stop the public health cuts and received a reply? Do you have a conservative MPP?…
May 09
RT @JILLSLASTWORD: Dear @samoosterhoff, my constituency staff have put together a step-by-step guide on how to respond to peaceful protesto…
May 09
RT @Lib_Techie @MichaelTibollo That is a lie Ontario Library Services is essential to day to day operations of libraries and service to pa…
May 09
RT @oursacredbreath @MichaelTibollo Our library just announced no more inter library loans outside our municipality ... so you are wrong .…
May 09
RT @Thamahmmy @MichaelTibollo @BPCRPL You have obviously never used a rural library. We depend on each other’s resources to provide the be…
May 09
RT @malloryapearce @MichaelTibollo "No involvement in the day-to-day operations of public libraries..." So what would we call this? https:…
May 09
RT @malloryapearce @MichaelTibollo Just so that we're really clear on the direct impact on the day to day operations of libraries, I'd lik…
May 09
RT @malloryapearce @MichaelTibollo This is a completely incorrect statement. SOLS is responsible for the delivery of library materials mul…
May 09
RT @andrewpyper @MichaelTibollo Your statement wildly misrepresents the facts, and is ignorant of how Ontario’s library services functions…
May 09
RT @mridley @MichaelTibollo Wrong. The powerful & *cost effective* collaboration among libraries and agencies such as these is undermined…
May 09
RT @Kurt__McKnight @MichaelTibollo Another disaster by this government. The inter-library loan service is a must for rural libraries @b
May 09
RT @daniellemuma @MichaelTibollo So what you’re saying is that you LITERALLY have no clue what SOLS and OLS-N do, and you can’t be bothere…
May 09
RT @lilmisslibrary @MichaelTibollo These "arm length" agencies are critical to libraries! The InterLibrary Loan service is used by thousan…
May 09
#LibraryWarriors outside PC $1600 plate fundraiser w/ MPP @MichaelTibollo#Onpoli $$$ dinner while library budget… https://t.co/Tnfx8L6Tty
May 08
RT @progresstoronto: Did you see the new poll today? The majority of Ontarians oppose Premier Ford’s cuts to education! If you oppose the c…
May 08
Beyond shameful. MPP@samoosterhoff⁩ office calls cops on library-loving seniors | https://t.co/Os61nKos6I ⁦… https://t.co/tfusRWN9wO
May 08
RT @TorontoStar: Premier Doug Ford’s relentless, reckless cutting affects residents in cities, suburbs and rural areas — everyone but the r…
May 07
RT @LibrarianshipCA: Provincial minister says cancellation of inter-library service was a surprise https://t.co/39L3lPKfcS Minister Tiboll…
May 04
RT @GShankz: An investment in our libraries is an investment in #Ontario’s future #Sols @Local4948 @CUPEOntario https://t.co/dyEQykhptK
May 04
RT @4948Warriors: Tell Premier Ford to reverse cuts to the inter-library loan program. Take action now. https://t.co/GXz9FYjYmB@Local4948
May 03
Ontario's #publiclibraries are under attack from Ford Govt. Please sign +share! https://t.co/Lq9nSSVz7ghttps://t.co/n2gYzrb3Zr
Apr 30
Richmond Hill Library: more bad news for #PublicLibraries + the public who depend on them. https://t.co/tnJoH0BJNThttps://t.co/Ibw3GA7NYn
Apr 30
Great statement from MPP @Jennkfrench from Oshawa against the #OnPoli Ford Govt's drastic cuts to #publiclibrarieshttps://t.co/0bL2Xy4rkA
Apr 30
RT @shelleysavor: I'm actively protesting the cuts to healthcare in Ontario #PeopleHaveThePower! https://t.co/7veXPiQWih
Apr 28
RT @larsenesque: Ontario librarian calls minister's suggestion service be 'more efficient' after 50% cut an 'outrage' | CBC News https://t.
Apr 28
RT @CUPE129: Support Library Services in Pickering The Southern Ontario Library Service (SOLS) and Ontario Library Service - North (OLS-N…
Apr 28
RT @cupe932: Waterloo Region library staff speak out about end of interlibrary book-loaning service | https://t.co/9k4heGnDOd https://t.co/
Apr 28
RT @politicsfisher: I have never signed a petition in my life that is until today ... calling on the @fordnation govt to reverse its planne…
Apr 25
#DayofMourning 2019 event jointly presented by @Local4948 @torontolibrary Sharon from Mobile Crisis Intervention… https://t.co/u4dwVKya5y
Apr 24
RT @cupe932: Fort Erie feels pain from provincial funding cuts https://t.co/jVktNTw9wl
Apr 24
RT @Shelly__Gordon @dmrider @fordnation @TorontoStar I don't want my taxes to go to giant multinational corporations that make beer. I wan…
Apr 24
RT @maritstiles: Please sign this petition. We need to fight back HARD against this $1billion cut to front line public health services #TO
Apr 24
RT @progresstoronto: Doug Ford is cutting billions from public health, which could mean the end of student nutrition programs, sexual healt…
Apr 23
RT @cupe932: Cuts to Ontario library services devastating to under-served populations, says librarian https://t.co/SJz6ZsMSn5
Apr 23
Doug Ford: Stop the cuts to the Southern Ontario Library Service and Ontario Library Service - North - Sign the Pet… https://t.co/HFJAz8B1f8
Apr 21
National conversation on incidents in public libraries @tplwu4948Pres @4948Warriors Social workers, snacks and 'a… https://t.co/x1ALSqUX8Y
Apr 21
#LibraryWarriors need support/staffing to ensure staff/public safety + protect vulnerable populations.… https://t.co/QFjCSk17FP
Apr 20
Shame on the Ford Govt @TPLWU4948Pres @4948Warriors @CUPEOntario#ONPoli #topoli #librarywarriors Public Libraries… https://t.co/Rty8VqSXdQ
Apr 20
RT @jannarden: Province slashes Ontario Library Service funding by 50% https://t.co/sts3BU515L reading gave me a career and saved me a few…
Apr 20
Heartbreaking news. The Ford Govt is not for the people. Public Libraries are @jannarden @TPLWU4948Preshttps://t.co/ECEapeIueH
Apr 19
RT @torontolabour: Budget cut a sign that Doug Ford’s contempt for libraries persists https://t.co/4TzS1ZU5BY via @torontostar @Local4948
Apr 19
RT @CUPE391: We agree that this is a shameful action by the Ontario government! Libraries are among the most important public institutions…
Apr 19
RT @wylie_alan: Solidarity to all my colleagues and comrades in Canada fighting against 50% cuts to Ontario’s library system ️…
Apr 19
RT @GShankz: Libraries are the great equalizer giving knowledge and resources to all- no matter what their position in life..unlike @fordna
Apr 19
RT @TorontoStar: The Southern Ontario Library Service and the Ontario Library Service-North will see their budgets halved for the 2019-20 f…